To mark the 60th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Government of Switzerland asked eight individuals with extensive human rights experience to join together to reflect on contemporary human rights challenges and develop in the form of an Agenda for Human Rights.
The work of the Eminent Persons Panel was also supported by the Governments of Norway and Austria which facilitated working meetings in Oslo and Vienna during 2008.
The Panel’s text Protecting Dignity: An Agenda for Human Rights is being presented to the Government of Switzerland and to the wider international community on the occasion of the 60th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
It is hoped that this document, together with the follow-up research projects on select issues listed below, will encourage over the coming years further dialogue and action to improve respect for human rights around the world.
Sixty years ago, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights proclaimed that « recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of the human family is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world ».
Since the Declaration’s adoption, the vast majority of
governments have formally incorporated international
human rights standards into their national law and
constitutions, and an ever widening circle of organizations
and civil society networks from across the
globe have called for accountability. These organizations
have themselves increasingly integrated human
rights principles into their own policies and practices.
Yet today the dignity of millions of people continues
to be violated as a result of weak or ineffective
governance, corruption, poverty, oppression, and war.
From the ill-treatment of those in detention to the
situations of many more lacking access to adequate
food, basic health care, and opportunities for decent
work, from the failure to protect civilians in danger
to the lack of effective action to confront human
trafficking, from the plight of migrants and stateless
persons to the devastating impact of violence against
children, these and other affronts to the dignity and
rights of our fellow human beings shame us all.
As a group of independent individuals asked to identify
major challenges and to offer proposals for future
action, we believe it is essential to return to what binds
the human family together – recognition of our shared
humanity and dignity. Doing so is the best way to
forge a new consensus around a long term vision and
strategy – one which recognizes that sustained
protection of human rights requires both effective
national institutions and enhanced global accountability.
Human Rights Today
The gaps between recognition of human dignity and
the realization of human rights remain wide – and have
arguably grown even wider in recent years. Cold War
divisions have given way to new forms of polarisation
between North and South in key areas of policy,
including trade, aid, and the environment.
The emergence of a more security-driven political
environment in reaction to horrible terrorist attacks has
been accompanied by acts of arbitrary detention, torture
and enforced disappearance, and other serious assaults
on human dignity. We emphasise that all measures taken
to combat terrorism must comply with international
human rights, refugee and humanitarian law.
Despite the fact that the Universal Declaration has
been affirmed and reaffirmed by every government,
it is regrettable that a shared understanding of
human rights globally remains elusive. Rights are still
sometimes perceived as embodying western rather
than universal values. Some affirm civil and political
liberties but do not recognize economic, social and
cultural rights. Others degrade civil and political rights
and respect for the rule of law, claiming the need to
secure economic and social stability first. The Universal
Declaration was conceived as a careful balance of
individual freedoms, social protection, economic
opportunity and duties to community. This holistic
vision is as relevant today as it was sixty years ago.
Meeting the Challenge of Poverty
Today, more than one billion people – one in every six human beings – live in conditions of extreme poverty.
The vast majority are women. A human rights strategy for the decades ahead must effectively address the
7 challenge of poverty. Poverty is an immensely complex phenomenon, rooted in exploitation, discrimination,
unequal access to assets, location, capacity, alienation from public institutions, and the legacies of history. No one need be destined to this fate. Poverty can be eliminated by protecting and empowering the most marginalized.
The United Nations Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) mark progress in this regard because governments
have made concerted commitments and set an unusually long time horizon for achieving results. How humbling it is therefore to realize that in 2008, after the immense efforts that have been made to bring
the MDGs forward and encourage public and official support for them, at the half-way point to the target date of 2015 we already know that most of the poorest countries will not be close to halving poverty or to achieving the other goals which governments solemnly committed to achieving at the start of this century.
This is not to say that rapid progress can never be
made. The vast sums that have been recently invested
to combat inequities in global health, notably by
multi-stakeholder alliances of governments, the private
sector, civil society actors and private philanthropy,
have had a demonstrable impact on the global vaccine
market, on the incidence of tropical diseases, and on
health services and immunisation programmes:
millions of people have benefited. Yet these initiatives
and the organizations involved have been among the
most outspoken in stressing that lack of institutional
capacity at national level represents the greatest
obstacle to further progress.
Access to Justice and the Rule of Law
Strengthening national capacities to combat poverty in turn requires effective institutions which ensure respect for the rule of law. The reality is that billions
of people are excluded from enjoying legal rights and protections. In many states judicial and law enforcement systems remain too weak, under-resourced or corrupt to carry out the tasks assigned to them. Efforts to support governments to build and reform their institutions too often assume that this monumental task can be accomplished in a few years. The consistent reiteration of unrealistic targets merely nourishes disappointment and failure. It is therefore crucial to invest in building effective national protection systems for human rights. By this, we mean institutional arrangements that function under a national constitutional and legal order to ensure that human rights - based on the international commitments of states - are protected. That includes the courts, police, prisons, social ministries, legislature, as well as national human rights institutions and other official monitoring bodies.
Human rights cannot be realized in the absence of
effective and accountable institutions. Where courts
are corrupt, over-burdened and inefficient, basic civil
rights will be violated. Where social ministries are
under-resourced, disempowered or lack qualified
staff, basic rights to adequate health care, education
and housing will remain unfulfilled. Effective national
protection systems, including properly constituted
national human rights institutions, must be complemented
by space for civil society and human rights
defenders, and support for their relationship
with the formal system of promoting and protecting
human rights.
A Global Fund for National Human
Rights Protection Systems
It is true that reforming and building sound national
institutions is a long, complex and expensive process
that is rarely newsworthy. But it is essential. Though
important work is being done to strengthen institutions,
for example, in the fields of health and education,
far too little emphasis has been placed on ensuring
access to a well-functioning justice system.
We therefore call for the establishment of a new Global
Fund for National Human Rights Protection Systems.
This new Global Fund should draw on lessons learned
from initiatives in health and other areas, and build
on the recognition of the importance of preventive
strategies and the need for effective and accountable
justice systems.
Recognizing Shared Responsibilities
Though national action is fundamental, states also need
to develop more effective international arrangements
for addressing global problems. In this context, international
human rights law must be developed so that
it can more effectively regulate issues of accountability
and cooperation between states, and define the responsibilities
and accountability of non-state actors.
Consider the urgent human rights dilemmas posed
by climate change. Few dispute that climate warming
is likely to undermine the realization of a broad range
of internationally protected human rights: rights to
health and even life; rights to food, water, shelter and
property; the rights of indigenous and traditional
peoples; rights associated with livelihood and culture;
with migration and resettlement; and with personal
security in the event of conflict. Responsibility for
human rights abuses linked to climate change often
lies not with the government nearest to hand, but
with diffuse actors, both public and private. This means
recognizing shared responsibilities for human rights.
A World Court of Human RightsOne future step which seems to us essential in
addressing many of these issues is the establishment
of a fully independent World Court of Human
Rights. Such a court, which should complement
rather than duplicate existing regional courts, could
make a wide range of actors more accountable for
human rights violations. We are convinced that progress towards the establishment
of a World Court of Human Rights, together with a
new Global Fund dedicated to strengthening national
justice systems, would constitute constructive initiatives
to protect human dignity in the 21st century.
|